The best bait for a trap is a food that is high in sugars and fasts. In particular, baits that have stood the test of time are peanut butter, milk chocolate, and milk chocolate covered peanut butter. The ultimate, classic mouse traps that always seems to do the job are the peanut butter snap traps—if you need to quickly get rid of some mice.. Instead of using a lot of bait on one trap, set more mouse traps. The best thing for mouse traps is that it only takes a pea-size piece of bait to allure mice to a trap to set it off. Specialty Mouse Baits. Another type of food bait you can use to put on mouse traps to catch mice is cooked or raw deli meat.
And the more forceful a mouse gets, the more likely a trap will get triggered. This is bad news for the mouse and good news for you. Peanut Butter. We saved peanut butter for last because, of all the food bait items that get discussed across the web, this one receives consistent mention as the best mouse trap bait.. Once you have found the right humane mouse trap to try out, the next step is to find the best bait for mouse traps. There are hundreds of different things you can try as bait, but many will often not work as well. Mice are very opportunistic species, which means they will adapt to many different living conditions.They can survive well with a little food and very little water for a long period.